Judge Evaluation - PR #46
Verdict: PASS
The evaluation used the approved spec and pinned 1f1e2e4ff3961a9808cf3336ad33dd9eda5d6ff0..33d0d07c4876577eab0a1d5da26874b8c7a2d972 diff. It judges planned slice I-4 independently of the implementation rationale, not the unfinished seven-slice feature.
Rubric Evaluation
| # | Criterion | Result | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| R5 | Lifecycle and idempotency | PASS for I-4 contribution | Execute is target-explicit, daemon-authoritative, and replay-safe after completion; previews are nondestructive and persist only bounded proposals/evidence. |
| R6 | Consequential mutation safety | PASS for I-4 contribution | All seven planned families use five-minute receipts, revalidate live evidence before first execution, reject stale or mismatched requests, and omit unsafe eviction. |
| R7 | Safe documents and observability | PASS for I-4 contribution | Stack documents are fixed-path, structured, size-bounded, fingerprinted, link-safe, validated, and atomically replaced under shared CLI/Desktop policy. |
Scope Check
- Scope creep found: No.
- Details: Focused public socket/client routes are the minimum daemon boundary required to keep receipt evidence and execution authoritative. Shared document primitives remove duplicate policy without broadening the renderer surface.
Gap Check
- Unaddressed I-4 behavior: None.
- Feature-level gaps: Six Docker snapshot and launcher coordination tools, launcher credential custody, CLI/Desktop setup, and final packaged host/process/ Docker verification remain explicitly assigned to I-5 through I-7.
Contradiction Check
No contradiction was found. MCP callers cannot supply stored proposals or evidence at execute time, raw stack-document contents are not returned, preview helpers do not perform their target mutations, and completed receipt replay is stable even if the world later changes.
Concerns
Process- and Docker-derived evidence is represented in the receipt design but the real-host evidence-change matrix is intentionally deferred to I-7. This does not weaken the deterministic I-4 tests or its daemon-authoritative contract.