Spec Evaluation - PR #46
Verdict: PASS for planned slice I-4; complete-feature criteria remain NOT YET.
Slice evaluation
| Requirement contribution | Result | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Consequential preview/execute protocol | PASS | Seven action families create five-minute receipts from explicit proposals and fresh evidence, then execute only after daemon-side evidence revalidation. |
| Replay and stale refusal | PASS | Completed receipts replay their persisted result; incomplete receipts reject expiry, target mismatch, proposal mismatch, and changed evidence without performing the action. |
| Action-specific schemas | PASS | All 16 I-4 tools have closed, typed input and output schemas rather than generic JSON payloads. |
| Canonical document policy | PASS | Shared primitives enforce the fixed filename, canonical existing directory, regular-file/no-symlink policy, size bound, validation, fingerprinting, and atomic compare-before-replace. |
| Desktop compatibility | PASS | The Desktop stack-document adapter now delegates to the same shared safety primitives, with its existing behavior and tests preserved. |
| Safe action boundaries | PASS | Preview helpers are side-effect free, execute callers submit only receipt plus explicit target, and unsafe any-owner eviction is not exposed. |
Acceptance criteria status
| AC | Status after this slice | Evidence / remaining work |
|---|---|---|
| AC1 | NOT YET | Stdio authority remains correct; final packaged macOS/Linux proof remains I-7. |
| AC2 | NOT YET | The bridge now exposes 45 strict tools; six Docker snapshot and launcher-operation tools remain I-5. |
| AC3 | PASS | Already satisfied in I-2 and unchanged by this slice. |
| AC4 | NOT YET | I-3 custody remains intact; launcher-operation credential custody and final leakage proof remain I-5/I-7. |
| AC5 | NOT YET | Consequential action replay passes; Docker snapshot and launcher coordination remain I-5, with final host replay coverage in I-7. |
| AC6 | PASS for I-4 contribution | Every planned consequential family uses a five-minute, evidence-bound preview/execute receipt and refuses stale execution. Final host/process/Docker evidence-change cases remain I-7. |
| AC7 | NOT YET | Canonical structured stack documents are complete; Docker endpoint snapshots and final observability proof remain I-5/I-7. |
| AC8 | NOT YET | Standalone build succeeds; CLI/Desktop setup and full host/platform matrix remain I-6/I-7. |
No incomplete feature-level criterion is marked complete in tracker.md.